---
title: "Does SEO Exist in China? The Chinese Internet from the Inside | Natalia Witczyk"
description: "Natalia Witczyk, an international SEO specialist, describes China's mobile-first internet of Baidu and WeChat, where even Baidu now invests in SEO."
podcast: "Globalne Horyzonty"
host: "Rafał Moszkowców"
guest:
  name: "Natalia Witczyk"
  role: "International SEO specialist"
topics:
  - "China"
  - "Baidu"
  - "WeChat"
  - "international SEO"
  - "live selling"
duration_min: 53
published_at: 2026-05-15
video_url: "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-k5Ij7Wrzhc"
url: "https://moszkowcow.com/podcast/natalia-witczyk-china-baidu-wechat/"
---

# Does SEO Exist in China? The Chinese Internet from the Inside | Natalia Witczyk

## About the guest

- **Who she is:** Natalia Witczyk, an international SEO specialist who lives in Barcelona. This is her second appearance on Globalne Horyzonty.
- **What she does:** She works mainly with Google and Bing, and also with Baidu, and in the past with Yandex and Naver. She recently came back from a six-month stay in China, where she worked with a local agency, analyzed Baidu and got to know the Chinese internet from the inside. She also writes for International Search News.
- **What we talk about:** Life and work in China, technical challenges (VPNs, payments, mobile-only apps), Chinese agencies, WeChat and other platforms, content control, Baidu entering Google, live selling, and what Europe can learn from the Chinese approach.
- **Where to find her:** LinkedIn (Natalia Witczyk) and her articles at International Search News.

## Best quotes

> “China is not desktop at all.”

> “Do not build a website. Instagram and Google Business Profile.”

> “SEO is probably not dying, if in 2026 a tech giant from China says: let us invest in SEO.”

> “Something very valuable in China is launching a project very fast, burning through an idea very fast and seeing whether it works or not.”

## Transcript

Host: Rafał Moszkowców. Guest: Natalia Witczyk.

### Introduction

**Rafał:** Do you wonder what happens when an SEO specialist from Europe lands in a world where Google practically does not exist? Yes, yes, there is such a world. Natalia Witczyk, because that is who we are talking about, has just come back from a six-month stay in China, where she worked with a local agency. Day to day she analyzed Baidu, worked with WeChat and generally got to know the Chinese internet from the inside. In today's episode of Globalne Horyzonty we talk about the future of search engines, the present of marketing, of course we also talk about artificial intelligence, and about why the West, in quotation marks, may completely fail to understand the direction in which our digital world is heading. Natalia has huge experience not only with Google or Bing, she has also worked with Yandex, with Baidu and with Naver, a nod here to South Korea. So this will be a conversation that definitely goes beyond our Western internet, and I think that is why it is doubly interesting. Enjoy the listen.

**Rafał:** Hi Natalia. Welcome back to Globalne Horyzonty.

**Natalia:** Hi Rafał. Thank you very much for inviting me again.

**Rafał:** The pleasure is mine, because I verified that last time, so I feel good about it. Maybe remind the listeners who did not listen to or watch our first meeting who you are and what you do.

**Natalia:** My name is Natalia Witczyk, day to day I live in Barcelona, although as it will soon turn out from the conversation, sometimes I am elsewhere in the world, but that is usually temporary, because my base is in Barcelona. I do purely international SEO. Mainly Google, that is where the clients are, but also Bing, recently Baidu too, and in the past I had the chance to work a bit with Yandex and a bit with Naver. I try to widen these global horizons of mine when it comes to search engines.

**Rafał:** A beautiful reference, it came out great. But seriously, the reason for our conversation is that you came back from China, where you spent half a year, and I am incredibly curious what you learned there and what you can tell us and our listeners about it. The topic of China in Poland is very hot, also in the context of potential expansion or building footholds in Asia, in China in particular or in Vietnam. I personally get such questions, but I have absolutely no answers to them, so maybe this will help us a bit today. I have an idea for four thematic blocks. The first is a bit about what it was like living in China. The second, what the ecosystem looks like, because it is completely different there, I think that will turn out in this conversation, from Europe. The third, what we can draw from it, and at the end, how it changed you. Does that work for you?

**Natalia:** Great. I think these are great blocks, great questions. I am already thinking in answers, something I learned, I will improvise.

**Rafał:** You certainly learned some Mandarin, from what I heard.

**Natalia:** Yes. I started intensive lessons before leaving. Then on site I had not one but two teachers, because there is nothing better than a teacher who keeps saying how fast you learn, how great you are doing, because they simply do not know that the same week I take the same lessons with someone else. I did twice as well. I keep taking lessons after coming back too. It is my ambition for the next few years, because I think it will take a few more years to reach a decent level, to understand the language a bit, to get a taste of it.

**Rafał:** Apparently learning languages is the best protection against Alzheimer's, so a good direction.

### What surprised Natalia Witczyk most after arriving in China?

**Rafał:** Last time we talked you were packing for many things. I am curious what surprised you most. What could you not predict while you were still in Barcelona?

**Natalia:** Oh, great question. What I did not manage to predict was how unprepared my digital ecosystem is for using the internet in China. I thought I would go with Google Translate installed in the browser and a reasonably good VPN and handle everything as I went, buy everything online with just that translator, click through everything. And it turned out you have to approach it completely differently: China is not desktop at all. So my thinking about which tools I would use in my normal browser, on my Mac, totally collapsed, because for example it was a big surprise that most e-commerce apps work only on mobile. Only as an app, there is no website, no desktop interface, everything is in the phone. That was the first big point of surprise.

**Rafał:** I had something similar, although I was in China very briefly. I noticed there seem to be no websites there, and if there are, nobody cares about them. How did you deal with it? Because I had a problem with a VPN, getting a VPN working on the phone.

**Natalia:** First of all, the VPNs we know, the most popular ones, none of them work, we have to say that clearly. What is very popular the Chinese government will block, because using a VPN is not entirely legal in China. So you have to look for very small solutions, very niche companies. I can say it out loud, the Chinese government probably does not listen to this podcast, so they will not block it, I hope: my favorite VPN is ProtonVPN and it actually still works in China. Slowly, with hiccups, but it works.

And how did I cope? One of the elements that helped me most, and I literally used most apps this way, was buying a second phone, a Chinese one, with a Chinese phone number, with a Chinese system that of course had no Google, with the apps for that system, and my European phone with the camera on top, with live translation. That is exactly how it looked and it was the best way.

**Rafał:** Necessity is the mother of invention, as we can see. By the way, I also recommend Proton, I did not use ProtonVPN specifically but other tools, and we help them a bit in a few matters, so that too, incidentally.

### How does a Chinese SEO agency work?

**Rafał:** What did your typical working day in a Chinese agency look like? I am totally curious how these agencies work from the inside, what the pace is, the structure, the relationships, how they communicate with clients, how similar or distant it is from what we do in Europe.

**Natalia:** The agency I worked in was a very interesting case, because it is a Chinese agency with about 50 employees. My direct boss was a guy from Germany who has lived in China for many years, has a Chinese wife and has resided there for almost a decade. In that agency he had the role of the Google specialist for Chinese companies who want to go abroad, so he had that part of the business under him. On top of that he supported the Chinese SEO team on quality in matters like running tests and expanding reports. And I was a kind of add-on to what he does, the Western perspective.

The first shock, which threw me off, but then I understood that this is exactly how China works: in that agency 50 people work on computers that do not have a Windows license, only pirated copies. And they do not have Microsoft Office, which was a shock for me, because AI or no AI, you have to use Excel. In my life it is the foundation of working with any data, I even make reports in Excel often just so they look nice. And here it turns out there is no Excel. LibreOffice. I do not know if you ever had the chance to use that monster.

It is that Chinese approach: wherever it can be cheaper, it will be cheaper, unless there is an actual business need. As they told me: but what is the business need? I could not justify it. I could not say we would save this much time or earn this much more money because we use Excel instead of LibreOffice. That is very Chinese thinking: point zero is the minimum cost resistance. The Chinese guys and girls in the office had no problem with it, they also had no other point of reference. I came with my Western approach that there is always Excel, so what are we talking about? And it turns out you can do without Excel. Even that German lost these battles and works that way too.

And labor in China is very cheap in general. A very junior employee of an SEO agency earns very little, but has the ambition to earn more in the future, so for them it is an investment. So the approach to work: we prefer four juniors to one senior, often. And you can see it in the results of the work. And the agencies that stand out, that do it better, invest a bit in seniors, so that in the structure of the agency there is someone who has things under control and some experience. But it is not a structure of specialists in a subject, rather of someone who will find out fast and learn fast.

**Rafał:** That very much resembles a certain country in Central Europe.

**Natalia:** It has nice similarities, but in China it is at the extreme. I think we have gone several steps ahead and often do not even realize it. And China not yet. It has not yet invested in quality to the degree I might have thought it wants to, but it is not there yet.

**Rafał:** I remember being in China last year, at Tencent. We talked about data generally: a bit of a lecture, a bit of a workshop, a bit of a conversation. A presentation about that organization was displayed, what it consists of, data analytics generally. In the bottom right corner it said: "Activate your Windows". I had a "what the actual..." These are micro-savings. Even such a gigantic company, incredibly rich, a kind of Facebook plus of the Chinese market, with no problem at all. What is the problem? It works, so I think I understand what you are talking about.

### How do the Chinese think about SEO and PPC?

**Rafał:** You were recently at Kulturalnie o SEO and people reported to me, first, that you gave a very nice presentation, so congratulations. And second, that you said you tried to explain to the Chinese that you specialize in SEO, and supposedly they did not quite understand what it means, that in this narrow scope. I wonder how Chinese companies think about online marketing at all. Is there even something like: hey, this is the SEO department?

**Natalia:** An SEO department is a mega rare creature. It is really a search engine department, and in that department the same person handles both SEO and PPC. They do not feel the need to separate one from the other. On top of that, a person who invests in advertising and knows what is going on there understands where SEO has a chance to stand out and where it simply cannot break through the noise of Baidu, which takes most of the SERP with its own products. Advertising is inevitable and this is a person who has knowledge of both disciplines at once and analyzes the data together. And it is interesting that in China very often the marketing department does not know anything about SEO or PPC. It delegates everything to a company that does, and you actually talk to the owner of the company, the owner of the e-commerce business, some founder, because that is usually the person in a Chinese organization who speaks the best English.

I am speaking totally from the perspective of a person who helps do SEO on Google in a Chinese company, for example an e-commerce company that sells to the US or to Europe. They come to an agency like ours, they know we have Chinese-speaking people, so day to day they talk with the team, and when we need to talk strategy, it is my German boss or me and we talk to them in English about bigger plans or presentations. And then it turns out the founder is the person who makes the budget decisions, who does not need to understand where SEO starts and where PPC ends, and most often does not know. He talks about results for him, meaning how much we will sell: if we put in this much money, what will come of it? And then you sit with your team and say: okay, out of this money how much goes to advertising, how much to SEO, when do we do what? When does it pay off to separate those two topics, and when do we throw everything into one basket because we want fast results. That is mega interesting, because we do a bit of that, but not quite. I have the feeling SEO is constantly separated a bit from the rest. I think for a very long time we will have to think completely globally, because there is no other way.

**Rafał:** Sorry for laughing, but this is incredible. God, I have gone against the current my whole life. We as an organization gave up PPC at the beginning of the year, because we had a PPC department and combined everything, but we decided that to deliver ultimate quality, to really understand and do AI, and Bing, and search broadly, organic, and multimodal too, we could not also do PPC, the blanket is too short. And now you come and say that no, you have to go the other way.

**Natalia:** I think that in Europe the price of quality is still very high, that it is worth paying, that companies understand it. In China, because speed counts more and the lowest cost, just so it gets done well, and not splitting yourself into four, they do not do it, but that does not mean it will be the same for us. I think we may differ when it comes to the future. In a few years we will find out, as usual.

**Rafał:** Then it will turn out. I really try to specialize in organic, but it is also a question of whether people will appreciate it and for how long, because it depends on those companies' margins. Then they can afford many specialists. About China I have a feeling similar to yours: fast, fast, fast is the most important thing, and the effect in the form of: okay, how much will land in my account, rather than how many clicks I will get. I suppose there are matters of conversion optimization, funnels, paths, but the owner probably says: please do it. Okay, but do they want to pay well or not?

**Natalia:** I think that if you are a referral, if you have some way in, meaning you are in a sales conversation with them not from cold calling but from some contact, then they are able to pay well. Especially for, I will say it directly, a white face. If they want to do SEO on Google, and they are from China, have no office and do not live outside China, they will invest in someone who is outside China, they will trust, especially if it is a referral. In China everything is based on referral, on a good word from someone you know. That is part of the culture and business, absolutely.

**Rafał:** That also reminds me of a certain country in Central Europe.

### What is life like on the phone in China: WeChat and Meituan?

**Rafał:** Okay, let us go on. I noticed that in China the user lives in WeChat, mainly. Possibly in Alipay, everything was there too. I also noticed, when I was in China, that there are reels there, and I had no idea what was going on. The first few days I was in complete shock. They live in WeChat, in Alipay, then they buy through livestreams, pay with QR codes, search for something in Baidu, which has its own Wikipedia, Reddit, Medium. I honestly wonder, Natalia, how a Western European specialist finds her way in this. Where do you start, if you want to do anything in this ecosystem? How did you manage to handle it?

**Natalia:** The best step on my side was to sit down for lunch with a Chinese colleague from my office, to invite him to lunch of course, because that is a very nice gesture. I brought gifts from Europe, of course: chocolate is very valued in China, because Western sweets are not bought much there, as they are not of good quality, so if you bring them from abroad, they are better. And I say: so show me. And he shows me his phone, says: look, here you have this, here I have that. And copying what he does, because the speed of navigation, the way they interact with these apps, is something unimaginable. I will honestly admit, I think the Chinese forgave me: because I am most often a head taller, it was easy for me to look over their shoulders. I was simply fascinated by how they operate on their social media, what they watch, what they stop at, which apps they use, so with total persistence I looked over their shoulders in every possible situation to find out what is going on on their phones.

**Rafał:** Not nice, but I understand.

**Natalia:** Fortunately a certain closeness in public places is not a problem there, because their comfort zone is completely different, these are people used to crowds, so if you stand a step too close, it does not bother them at all.

**Rafał:** Your favorite app that you used there?

**Natalia:** I am a fan of Meituan. It is an app like our Glovo or Uber Eats, but there you have grocery shopping from a supermarket, you have everything: food, from a supermarket everything you want arrives in half an hour, from whichever supermarket you want. Because you basically send a guy on a yellow motorbike. You may have seen the yellow motorbikes. That is Meituan, so that he goes shopping for you. I got fascinated by it because in Meituan there are also reels and I could not understand it: you are shopping and watching videos? And he says: no, no, no, it is not about the person who is shopping. It is those drivers who are waiting for a delivery that is supposed to come in, they watch those videos in the break, and there are so many of them, because it is such a big part of the economy at the moment, that they themselves generate the traffic on those videos. You find entertainment in breaks from work, and when an order comes in right away, they see it right away in the same app and have to leave.

**Rafał:** It is hard to deny the business logic of that solution: once you have a user glued to the screen, show them something, maybe you can earn something. On one hand incredible, on the other a bit depressing, because I had the impression that while in Europe or the States people, or to put it the Poznań way, folks, are glued to smartphones, there it is a completely different level. They are like atoms moving between the metro and everything else without raising their eyes. There is a lot of very engaging content, and not only for young people, because I saw people of all ages who were completely glued to their phones.

**Natalia:** Older people totally glued, maybe even more than the young, because they have more time. Everyone technologically very capable, because there is no choice. There is no room for life without a phone. Without a phone you can do nothing, in many places you cannot pay any other way than with the phone, so even the oldest, most anti-technology person will eventually break through.

### Content control and privacy on Chinese social media

**Natalia:** That glue to the phone is very interesting, because there are several topics there that are worth mentioning. First: absolutely everyone staring at the phone, unless they notice you are a foreigner and they have seen few foreigners in their lives, then they raise their heads, look at you and open their mouths: who is that and what is she doing? Some strange girl from some strange country who is a head taller than everyone around. It happened that they could tear their heads away, but mostly they did not notice.

It is very interesting that the content on social media is very much under government control and very politically directed. It is not the same content as we watch at home on our social media, which is very polarizing, which needs a reaction to break through, which creates a kind of quarrel. Often, when a trend starts to break out that is not in line with the Chinese government, that trend is killed, its visibility is lowered. There was a trend quite recently, young people decided: why work if I will never get rich anyway, there is a crisis, so it is better to do things any old way and work the minimum. It was a big trend that happened at different moments around the world after covid, and in China it broke out especially and very quickly the party decided it was unproductive and not positive in any way, so it is better not to spread it. So that trend is lighter, less polarizing, often more pro: how great China is, or how terrible the States are. There is a mass of this content, non-stop.

The best type of videos that constantly show up on Chinese social media are clips from old US police series with Chinese subtitles. That creates the feeling that everywhere is dangerous, that in the States they kill someone all the time, because everything is murders, some NCIS or other series of that type, and showing worse crimes with an implication, because it is not said directly: look, in the United States it is some tragedy, some gun, some shooting, and with us it is so safe. They have a passion for seeing how bad it is for others and how great it is for them. And a mass of videos that fill all the feeds: what hits are great, those 20-second reels, various lights, huge buildings, modernity. This is China, the greatness of this nation.

**Rafał:** At the same time I saw that this is profiling at another level. There are about a billion four hundred fifty million or a billion four hundred million users of these various platforms there. I suppose GDPR, that is RODO in Polish, is not much in force.

**Natalia:** It does not exist at all. But nobody is afraid. The state knows everything. WeChat is not encrypted in any way and everyone knows it. You just have to behave. There is no other way. It is non-negotiable.

**Rafał:** There are people in Europe who think this is good and should be that way. I personally do not find myself in that space. I think elementary human rights are violated. But we will not go further into that, because this was supposed to be about marketing, SEO and other things, because they will shut us down in a moment. We will also say something about Trump, something will fall on my head, so better not.

**Natalia:** Such times.

### Why did Baidu Baike gain visibility in Google?

**Rafał:** I read your article yesterday or this morning on International Search News. I did not know about it, I have an article catcher that threw it up for me. You wrote that Baidu launched an international version of Baidu Baike and suddenly gained visibility in Google. The Chinese Google, because Baidu is de facto a kind of Chinese Google, or even Alphabet, doing SEO in the Western Google. I wonder what that says about the direction Baidu is going, or Chinese corporations in general.

**Natalia:** It is a very interesting step. Nobody especially expected it. It was first spotted by Lily Ray, because she noticed that the visibility of the Baidu domain in Google had risen a lot. And suddenly it turns out they set out with five language versions: English, Spanish, French, Japanese and Russian. They translated their top articles from their own Chinese version, they chose only some of those articles, they did not translate everything. It is a mega interesting case, because above all it is unique content, even though translated by their own AI, on topics of Chinese culture and history that Western sources do not describe as they do. I am curious myself whether Google will somehow catch them on using AI, or they will manage to keep that visibility, even build it further.

I cannot escape politics when I talk about China, because it simply does not work: a bit of soft power. It is better to talk about ourselves than to give Western sources total freedom in how they talk about us. I think there may be something in that. It is a big investment after all in these new languages. And on the other hand, SEO is probably not dying, if in 2026 a tech giant from China says: let us invest in SEO and we will just throw in content that is typically written for SEO, because you can see it in the whole structure of that text, it is optimized for Google, it even uses hreflang. And we have to say clearly that Baidu itself does not use hreflang, does not need it.

**Rafał:** Let us say what hreflang is, if you could.

**Natalia:** Hreflang is a kind of tag that Google and other search engines, but not Baidu, use to understand language versions and the relationships between them, meaning language and country versions of a site. If I have, for example, English, Polish and a special English version from Australia, I have to use three hreflangs to tell Google: listen, this is this version, this is the other one, and this is Australia, do not mix them up. Google needs such things because it is a global search engine that tries to sort out those country versions. Baidu officially works only in Mandarin Chinese, there is no support for example for Cantonese, so it does not need hreflang. There is only one language they care about. But they introduced hreflang in these international versions to give themselves a chance to show up in Google the way they should.

**Rafał:** So you think this is a soft power direction? I doubt that over several million URLs it was just some test, although it is not excluded, but rather unlikely that it is some general idea. Let me give you some context for why it moved me so much. I also talked to Chinese companies, I had the chance to talk with Tencent, Lenovo and a few others, and one thing kept recurring: hey, we are figuring out how to go abroad, whether with our data centers, like Tencent, or our games, or our AI solutions, like Lenovo, or our smart cities, that they are looking for this space, while knowing they are rather perceived in the West, in Europe, as a bit of a threat, for us a bit of poor quality, and in the States as a total threat. This is one of the signals of a big soft power attempt.

**Natalia:** I totally agree. I think it is going in that direction. And you have to add the context, which I think you surely have, but our listeners may not: there is a crisis in China at the moment. An economic crisis, you can feel it. You can feel that it will soon be even bigger. What was going on between them and the States affected them, but not only. China has become more expensive, production in China is no longer as cheap as it was. Now it is cheaper to produce in Vietnam, often in Cambodia, so some costs that used to be China's distinguishing feature are no longer so competitive. Besides, there is the problem of unemployment among young people who return from studies, for example in the United Kingdom, from super-universities, and a great job does not wait for them at all. This economy has failed those people a bit. There is a group of young, ambitious, educated people who have not found a place in society. The middle and upper middle class has shrunk a bit recently. And I think they look abroad as a natural direction to keep growing, to nibble off something more, because their own market is limited. The Chinese government does what it can, five-year plans, investments here and there, but it will take them a while to get out of this crisis.

### What happened to the real estate market in China?

**Rafał:** It is hard to get out of a crisis in such a huge economy. I learned, and again it reminds me of a country in Central Europe, that people there generally do not invest in the capital market. The average middle class, people who already have some money, absolutely do not invest in such a thing, bonds are rather not bought, Western stocks absolutely not, because of problems, sanctions, who knows what. Gold is not bought the way we do, there are no deposits in Switzerland or ETFs, we have loads of these things to do. There people constantly buy apartments. When I talked about the crisis with someone in China, one of the reasons that money is frozen is that a huge amount of cash is frozen in real estate. That raises the price of real estate, and that cash does not work in the economy, so domestic demand does not grow, and that creates another problem for young people, and that is why there is a demographic crisis in China. A gigantic problem with fertility, on a scale unseen in those regions of the world, perhaps except Japan or Korea, because people simply cannot afford an apartment. It reminds me a bit of Poland. Maybe not that scale, but a similar mindset: I am guilty myself, so it does not sound like I am judging anyone, my first thoughts about investment were: okay, we will buy an apartment.

**Natalia:** That housing crisis hit the Chinese very hard, because that real estate lost mega value. People could lose even 50 percent of their money in some weeks, months, because that bubble burst totally. There are whole ghost cities that were started and never finished, because there was simply no money. There is also a mass of people who invested money, and those apartments never came into being at all. And unfortunately in China this element appears that I think is rarely visible in the West too, because either someone is so against China that they do not even think about it much, or is so for it and likes that success so much that they do not see the negative parts. Of course everyone thinks they are in the middle. I think I am in the middle, I know it is a very big cognitive bias. There is no agency. As a small citizen you will not get your rights so easily. Someone owes a lot of money and it is not that they will catch him and do something about it, especially if he is some businessman known in the area who handles party money. The fertility topic is a totally different matter, which I do not want to comment on, because I am not a specialist, but the one-child policy, which ended recently, had a broad effect. It is not that from generation to generation you say no children, and then all the children, and people suddenly change their approach. For a Chinese person two children is a big family, simply a large family.

**Rafał:** I think similarly about it, looking from my perspective. But okay, we are not going into it, because it is a separate topic. You could talk about China for hours, it is so interesting and so many-threaded.

### What can Europe learn from China?

**Rafał:** I wonder what we can draw from your experiences, from the Chinese experience. My observation is that China operates on rented land. Let me explain what I mean. You build in WeChat, for example: WeChat is your platform on which you put your app, that app functions in the WeChat ecosystem, like a rented plot. Or in Baidu: you have no choice, you have to use rented space. And I read somewhere that Rand Fishkin even admitted that you have to come to terms with it, and that is supposedly a big thing.

**Natalia:** Rafał, are you quoting your own presentation from Kulturalnie o SEO? Because exactly that was on my slides.

**Rafał:** I read it in your presentation, as I say, people told me. We are wondering what Europe can learn from the Chinese approach.

**Natalia:** I think something very valuable in China is launching a project very fast, burning through an idea very fast and seeing whether it works or not. In Europe we are attached to process, to thinking for years about how to position a brand from scratch. I am not saying investing in a brand is bad, because it is good, but sometimes it is worth throwing an idea into the field, a product into the field, in a small version, and seeing whether it clicks. In China they do it brilliantly and you see it right away, even in times of crisis. You walk down the street, for example in my district, and every two, three weeks you can see a new business in the same premises. They have a tradition that when a new business opens, there are those nice wreaths from Chinese culture that neighbors and acquaintances buy for luck, so that it goes well and there is money. You see right away that it is a new business, because on the day it opens there is a mass of those wreaths. And literally every three weeks you see a new shop in the same place trying to click. And they see it does not work, so they pack up, they will not keep paying in and waiting to see whether it dies on its own or barely survives. If there are not the profits they defined for it to make sense, they close and do something else. That point of view is certainly worth noticing. Then you do not build a new website, a domain, with all the architecture, but maybe a mini app on a system that already works, and you add your branding. You do not have to start from scratch. Maybe you can start on social media alone before the company gets going, to have a huge amount of your own content. They grow those local businesses this way through WeChat. Nobody thinks about websites at all, because they are unnecessary. I think there is a lot to learn here: if the idea is good, it will defend itself, without all those super tools, without sites or systems built for the start.

**Rafał:** I wonder what will be such a platform for us in the Western world.

**Natalia:** Has a friend of a friend ever come to you who says: hey, you do this SEO, help me? A few weeks ago I got a friend who is a hairdresser, a super hairdresser who does great hairstyles, she goes to people's homes, for example older people, or to events, preparations. I say: hey, do not build a website. Instagram and Google Business Profile. It is really not worth investing in a new website, a domain from scratch, it will give you nothing. Instagram to the max, and optimize it so that all the photos and stories show your results, your hairstyles, your way of working. And that is enough for you. I even felt bad saying: pay me 200 euros a month and I will do something with it, because she simply will not rank, there is no chance. I think more and more it will be like this with small businesses, and in a moment bigger ones will jump into this kind of thinking. Not all of them: if you are a SaaS, if you are e-commerce, it is hard to hand everything over to others. But for example Google Merchant Center: why focus only on your own e-commerce when being at Google may pay off more? Maybe you will sell better in Merchant than only on your own site. And there we already start a whole series of ideas and strategies that are not on your website.

**Rafał:** I asked what will be a WeChat for us in Europe or the States, because we do not have one platform, but there are many such platforms. Recently, for example, I analyzed a site that earns solely and exclusively on Amazon. One hundred percent of revenue is on Amazon. The margin is 93 percent. About 40 percent is eaten by Amazon plus Amazon Ads. I am old school, I wanted to admit, you can see it too, because I did not shave. I see only risks, and these people say: what risks? It earns, we do not have to invest. They have an online store, but it does not pay for them to develop it, they also sell, they will do a TikTok Shop. They show me statistics: in the States such a project earned 30 thousand dollars in the first month, and in the third already 90. And he says: can you achieve something like that organically or with a paid online store? And here I shrank a bit. It depends, like in SEO, and seriously, I am completely unable to predict it. Maybe this is a lesson to stop fearing it and to see this land rented from someone as an opportunity.

**Natalia:** I think certainly, and the sooner we settle into this rented land, the easier it will be for us to dominate that land and use that channel as best we can for ourselves, because not everyone is doing it yet. As soon as TikTok Shop launches somewhere in Europe, and probably very soon, because it works great in the States, then better to be first than better, as the old marketing rule said. I think it will be a race of the brave who jump head first into the deep pool and fish out what they should.

### Will live selling catch on in Poland and the West?

**Rafał:** I am curious what will happen here. Indeed China teaches too and it seems to me it is worth looking at how companies work there, not on their own platforms, because that is certainly quickly scalable. But I wanted to ask about something else: live selling. In China it is the norm, I have the impression it goes on non-stop. In Poland I saw it a few times, but it probably does not convince me. I think it does not convince users either, but maybe I am wrong, I have not read any statistics. What is your opinion? Why has it not settled in the West yet? Or maybe it will not? Maybe it is cultural?

**Natalia:** It will settle for sure, it is a matter of time. Again I refer to my wonderful presentation from Kulturalnie o SEO, where I showed a slide with the old view of Mango teleshopping, which once won the hearts of Polish women and men. As a teenager I was fascinated by the world of Mango. I think that target group has changed in age, but it exists. That desire to buy a very specific product from people, well described and shown, exists. What is missing at the moment is a platform that allows very fast purchase. There is no platform where, watching a video, you click "buy now" right away, and right away delivery to your home, and in three clicks, without interrupting watching that video, I buy. From what I know, in Poland it is starting, for example, in second-hand shops: better thrift shops can do live selling, present a product that has arrived, and ladies in the comments buy. I say ladies because that is how it usually is, but I do not want to discriminate, users buy. It is not yet live selling fully in the Chinese version, because the point is for the user to buy with the checkout integrated right away. But again it is a matter of time. Maybe WhatsApp will introduce it first, because WhatsApp copies a lot from WeChat. That second option that is now appearing in WhatsApp already existed totally in WeChat several years ago. Or maybe TikTok will be first, because it has a good base from China in how that algorithm can work, and those payments. We will see. Or maybe some e-commerce from Poland. Maybe, for example, InPost will decide: we are making a 24-hour feed and will show new products every moment. In the morning kids' clothes, in the afternoon cosmetics, and in the evening building supplies. And right away with delivery to a parcel locker. It could really surprise, only it is a certain investment. The question is who will be ready to introduce such a sales and marketing infrastructure. But I think it is a matter of time.

**Rafał:** Damn, I think unfortunately you may be right. Indeed the crux is logistics. When you mentioned InPost I thought: in fact yes, logistics is the most important. They do it anyway, Vinted, only there you have to go through a process of two clicks.

**Natalia:** Rafał Brzoska, if you are listening, I am at your disposal. Write, I will do an SEO project for putting a parcel locker under my building in Barcelona.

**Rafał:** I already have one. Seriously?

**Natalia:** InPost has really moved into Spain, and of course I learned it from the WhatsApp group of Polish women in Barcelona, because I have such a Polish group of girls, that there is InPost and you can send parcels from home or receive them at home, whatever you need. It is loudly discussed by the Polish community in Barcelona.

**Rafał:** Okay, I was thinking only about Italy, because my sister happens to live in Italy and says: send it to me by InPost, and I say: you must have forgotten where you live, and she says: what do you mean, I have one by my house too. If Rafał Brzoska is listening, you are welcome, but I suppose unfortunately he may not be listening, so I will call him and pass on the recommendations if needed.

### What to know before a Polish company enters the Chinese market?

**Rafał:** Speaking of Polish companies: if a Polish company came to you and said, hey Natalia, we want to enter the Chinese market, what would be your top list of things they must know before they start spending yuan?

**Natalia:** The first question is what makes you think you will succeed in China. Why does your product have a chance in China? Price competition with the Chinese who produce in China is hard and probably hardly possible. What is the USP, unique selling point, to tell a Chinese person: listen, this is better than your domestic product of a similar line? I think the whole story starts there. Competition research, seeing who they would compete with, what domestic brands there are on the spot and whether they offer the same thing or something different. That is the best start. I have such a service that has recently been very popular: several companies from different parts of the world and industries contacted me for a kind of SEO market research, meaning using SEO tools to check who is on the market, what they sell and how they are doing. It sells very well, because loads of people want some methodology for doing market research, but more directed at marketing than anything else.

**Rafał:** That is interesting, because we also do something like that from the perspective of SEO data, the level of market share, but also keywords, volume, we calculate it in a certain way, dividing by CTRs and trying to work out how much potentially, also observing competitors. I think it is worth recommending, because it is neither an expensive nor a long service, it can be done fairly quickly. I recommend it warmly, because before you take the first step anywhere. Recently we had a client who wanted to go, just like that, quickly, to the Czech Republic. And I think for just like that, quickly, maybe go to Lublin. Another country is a lot of unknowns that have to be researched, starting with competition, saturation, potential prices and average prices. Let alone China.

### How did six months in China change Natalia Witczyk?

**Rafał:** Two last questions that I prepared. How did these six months change you? Do you think you might let yourself be persuaded and move to China, or will you rather visit occasionally?

**Natalia:** I will answer the second part of the question right away: occasionally, because legally, tax-wise and logistically it is very hard to live there. A mass of foreigners who live there permanently are on professional visas, you have to prove you cannot be replaced by a Chinese person. Whoever is there is a very elite group of specialists, engineers, experts in something, and if they are such experts, they have to lie about how much they earn, and pay taxes on a high salary, while earning for example half of it, in order to fit at all into those Chinese brackets for a super specialist, which are very far from reality. I know several such foreigners who do not earn at all what is on paper. I would not want that. I would not want to look for work in China and pretend I earn more than I do just to be able to be there at all. And I have great clients in Europe and in the States whom I do not want to lose. I will take advantage of the fact that China has opened up a lot, that there is still visa-free travel for Poles for up to 30 days, so you can drop in a few times a year for those 30 days, or drop into Japan for a week and come back, and the counter resets. I will use that, in fits and starts.

And what changed me most? I completely opened up to what the political point of view can look like. I think many people who go to China for the first time may have felt similarly: that the center of the world, which we think is in Europe, is not there at all. China suffered a lot historically, for example the Opium Wars. That was something I knew from hearsay, but I did not know the details at all. And what we say here, that Poland is now rising from its knees, they have exactly the same point of view. They now feel they are regaining the place that was given to them much earlier and was taken away from them. So they are ruthless when it comes to competing with the States or politics, because they feel they are only regaining their place. That seems fascinating to me, because when you think about what they do and why, from that point of view, the motivation looks completely different and you understand completely differently why they are so success-oriented and so hungry for that success, why they work so hard: they feel they finally can and that it gives them something. It totally changed my perspective. I am now reading a lot about the history of China and Asia, because my knowledge of it was very slight before I went there, really. I am even ashamed, but I think I am not the only one. It is a broader European problem.

**Rafał:** We learn from the perspective of the Piasts, and later from the perspective of Washington. I may not be very anti-American, but I am certainly not an Americanophile. A Sinophile, basically, probably not either. Nevertheless I think that part of the world, and China in particular, is a completely different civilization worth learning about. I will probably not learn Mandarin, although I never say never. It is definitely worth reading about China, about the Opium Wars, about other kinds of occupations, Russian-Chinese and Japanese wars, and what the Japanese did in Guangzhou or in Shanghai. The whole history is mega interesting.

### Recommendations and contact

**Rafał:** One last thing. One source of knowledge, a tool, maybe a book, or maybe a rule that you brought back from China and can recommend to everyone. What would it be? Let us start with a source of knowledge.

**Natalia:** Since I went to China, the well-known British guy in Europe, Dan Taylor, invited me to contribute to his site International Search News. And it turns out that this guy, even though he has never been to China in person, sits in the Chinese internet like nobody else and constantly puts out new news. I sometimes write something there once a month, and he updates daily on DeepSeek topics, investment topics. It is a great source of knowledge about what is happening in SEO, the internet and marketing in Asia. I recommend it.

**Rafał:** We will link it. And then a tool?

**Natalia:** Everyone from the West can download WeChat today. The WeChat we download from the Play Store is not the same WeChat that a Chinese person uses in China. It is a simplified version of the app, translated into English, without several functionalities. For example you will not see live selling and live feeds there, and in the Chinese version they exist, because I have both WeChats. What I do: I look at their social media very often. It is almost a way of forgiving myself for using social media in my free time, because at the same time it is research on Chinese culture. I look at what appears there, what trends they live by. I also follow a mass of people I met in China, so I see what they like, what they share, and I follow my nose along their trends, and their videos are fascinating. I am even looking right now for ways to download their videos so I can publish them on Instagram from an account I want to create: internet in China, social media in China. I will give references to the originals so people know what cool trends and ways of communicating exist in China, because it is completely different. Sometimes similar, sometimes completely different. Some of their obsessions are really mega interesting.

**Rafał:** I had a problem with WeChat in China, the Chinese WeChat with a British phone number. It did not work, then it started to work. But payments worked, I used UnionPay.

**Natalia:** You have to verify three times. You have to take a biometric photo, you need a passport.

**Rafał:** I also did it in a hurry, because I went a bit as I would in Europe, meaning I booked through Booking, because Airbnb probably does not work, an apartment. And of course nobody was waiting for me, there were no keys. I called that person and it was 4 pounds a minute, and that person did not speak English, and I said I do not have the key, and she said: WeChat. I say: I know, but I do not have the key. I joke that I paid more for that phone call and the attempt to communicate than for the apartment. I warmly recommend WeChat too, only it is nice to set it up before you go there.

**Natalia:** Verify everything beforehand, upload your passport, share payments, link Revolut or another card you have internationally, and later it runs great, but those first steps are harder.

**Rafał:** What about a rule? The Chinese are famous for proverbs, rules. Do you have something like that, something that stuck in your memory?

**Natalia:** Something stuck in my memory, but it is not from marketing. They laughed a lot in the office at my white food. White food, they have such a concept: it is healthy, boring, Instagram-style, diet food. Not that I would eat like that often, but it happened that I brought a Tupperware with such simple food and then I say: ah, white food, ha, ha, ha, white food.

**Rafał:** Oh damn, I had not heard that, very interesting what qualifies and what does not. Funny.

**Natalia:** Generally my approach to racism also changed a lot, because their approach to the white person is actually positive racism. It is hard to argue with it or to complain that it exists. But it has a side that lets you look in perspective at yourself, at the world, at relationships between people and how we see others, how others see us. That also opened my eyes a bit, because it is interesting how everyone looks at you from afar and you say: nice, and after a few months you simply have had enough. You have a really bad day at work, you are tired, you come back after long days, and someone takes photos of you without your permission. You have had enough and you think whether that privilege is worth that price, whether I even want it. It is a good way to evaluate your view of yourself in the world. Definitely as a white woman it is a huge privilege in such countries, there is no hiding that.

**Rafał:** An interesting conclusion. Natalia, thank you very much for this meeting and for sharing your experiences with us. It was really, really interesting. If our listeners wanted to find you and, for example, ask for more information, commission a market research or anything else, where is it easiest to find you?

**Natalia:** LinkedIn is my borrowed land. I invite you to contact me there. I will also say right away, sorry, I realize there was little marketing and more about China, because Chinese marketing is hard to fit into one short podcast, but I invite you to follow me, because when I can write about a specific case on some portal, I try to do it, so it may be more interesting there. And generally write with questions and I will gladly answer, as long as I can.

**Rafał:** Great, and you do not have to write in Mandarin, you can write in Polish. Thanks, Natalia, all the best. Bye.

**Natalia:** Thanks.

### Closing of the episode

**Rafał:** Thank you for listening to this conversation to the end. I hope Globalne Horyzonty widened your business map of the world today. So as not to miss further guests, be sure to subscribe to the channel and leave a trace in the comments. It helps me enormously to grow and reach new people. Find me on LinkedIn under my first and last name, and if you prefer a traditional form of contact, my email is always at your disposal. See you in the next episode.

## Guest's recommendation

- **International Search News, Dan Taylor** (website). Natalia recommends it as a great source of knowledge about SEO, the internet and marketing in Asia. Dan Taylor, although he has never been to China, follows DeepSeek and investment topics daily, and Natalia sometimes writes articles there.
- **WeChat in its Chinese version** (tool). Natalia advises following Chinese social media, because it is both cultural and trend research. The foreign version of WeChat is simplified, without live selling and live feeds.

Źródło: https://moszkowcow.com/podcast/natalia-witczyk-china-baidu-wechat/
